Best Practices Can Make You Worse
Copying what the best companies do feels safe and smart. Imported without their context, a best practice is just someone else's answer to a question you never asked.
Companies ask for "best practices" all the time. They want the playbook the winners use. The idea seems sound. Copy what works, and you should win too. But there is a catch. Best practices, copied carelessly, can make you worse. A practice can be perfect for one company. The same practice can hurt another. It all depends on the situation.
A best practice is an answer. But companies copy the answer without asking what question it solved. An answer to the wrong question just points you the wrong way.
Why the conventional wisdom is wrong
The common view treats best practices as always good. People see them as proven wisdom that is safe to copy. But a practice is "best" only for a certain situation. That means a certain size, market, stage, culture, and set of limits. Take it out of that situation, and what made it work is gone. You are left with a ritual that no longer fits. You copied the visible habit. You missed the hidden conditions that made it smart.
A practice that fits a 10,000-person company can crush a 20-person one. The smaller firm cannot afford that much process.
What works in a mature, stable market can be fatal in a young, fast-moving one. The new market often rewards the opposite move.
A practice tuned to one culture or business model causes friction when forced onto a different one. It does not boost results.
Copying the answer skips the thinking. So the team never builds the understanding to adapt when things change.
What is actually true
Here is the truth. There are very few universal best practices. There are only practices that fit a certain situation. The skill is matching the practice to the situation, not collecting practices. The companies people copy did not win by borrowing other people's playbooks. They won by knowing their own situation well. Then they built practices that fit it. Copy their practices without their understanding, and you copy the output of their thinking. You skip the thinking itself. And that was the part that mattered.
This is why copying admired companies so often lets people down. A startup adopts a giant's planning process. A small team imports an enterprise's org chart. A local business copies a national brand's playbook. Each one takes on a practice built for a situation it does not share. Then it wonders why the magic did not transfer. The magic was never in the practice. It was in the fit.
How to borrow without breaking yourself
Best practices are worth learning from. You just have to pull out the reasoning, not just the ritual.
Ask what problem the practice was actually solving before you adopt it. If you do not have that problem, you do not need the practice.
Check whether the conditions that made it work are conditions you truly share. Look at scale, market, culture, and resources.
Adapt it to your situation on purpose instead of installing it as-is. Expect your version to look different from the original.
Treat every "best practice" as a guess to test in your own situation. It is not a law to obey just because someone successful does it.
What TTGC sees
Clients often ask the team to copy what an admired competitor or category leader is doing. Part of the job is to ask whether that practice fits them first. Often it does not. The industry has watched this happen many times. A company adopts the marketing pace, hiring style, or operating habit of a business three sizes larger. That business is also three stages ahead. Then the smaller company suffers under process built for problems it does not have yet. So the better path runs the other way. Understand the client's real situation first. Then design or adapt practices to fit it. Sometimes that is the opposite of what the "best practice" says. Strong agencies are built the same way. They figure out what works for them rather than copy what worked for someone else. The practices that build a firm are rarely best practices. They are its own practices.
The honest take
Learn from the best, but do not blindly copy them. A best practice is an answer shaped by a situation. Import it without that situation, and it can quietly make you worse. You may end up heavier, slower, or aimed at a problem you do not have. Before you copy what a winner does, understand why it worked for them. Check whether their conditions match yours. Then adapt it on purpose to your own situation. The goal is not to do what the best companies do. It is to think the way they think. Then do what is best for you.
Sources
Harvard Business Review. Research on the limits of transferring best practices across different organizational contexts. hbr.org
TTGC. Patterns from building an agency and advising clients across many stages and sizes.
Ready to work with Through The Glass Creatives?
Book a free Brand and Growth Assessment and see exactly how the TTGC team would approach it.
Related reading: Why Logo Trends Are Dangerous · More Design Revisions Usually Produce Worse Results
